Dan Davies - "Back of Mind"

Share this post

surprises and how to spot them

backofmind.substack.com

Discover more from Dan Davies - "Back of Mind"

A newsletter of quiet contrarianism, slow analysis and ambient ideas
Over 2,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

surprises and how to spot them

a lawlike generalisation of sorts

Dan Davies
Jul 12, 2023
13
Share this post

surprises and how to spot them

backofmind.substack.com
4
Share

I’ve always wanted to have a law named after myself, like Murphy and Sodd and those guys.  I tried to coin one in the fraud book (“Anything that’s growing too fast needs to be checked out in a way it hasn’t been checked out before”), but the editors told me to knock it off.  They’ve also had a few tries in various drafts of the current book (“Decisions Nobody Made”, coming next year), but I keep plugging on nonetheless.

At present, I’m most keen on this little aphorism, which expresses my opposition to those virtuous but boring souls who caution against trying to make forecasts about our complex and surprising world:

the inclusion of this button was predictable and thus not a surprise

Davies’ Law: “If you don’t make predictions, you’ll never know what to be surprised by”.

(I even have a corollary; if you don’t make recommendations, you won’t know what to be disappointed by).

As with many such things, the law’s most useful if you reverse it.  If something seems surprising, ask yourself whether, if it had occurred to you to do so, you might have predicted it.  The multiple layers of counterfactuals pile up a bit there, but I think the concept is coherent.  As I’ve argued before, the majority of Black Swan events are not intrinsically unpredictable ones, they’re things which people could have predicted but didn’t.

In fact, the strategy of reversing the question can be applied multiple times.  When you see a business or organisation making an announcement that they are going to use Artificial Intelligence, the question to ask yourself is “ahead of time, would I have predicted that this would be one of the only entities in the economy that didn’t make use of something that looks like an incredibly generally applicable technology?”

Dan Davies - "Back of Mind" is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

13
Share this post

surprises and how to spot them

backofmind.substack.com
4
Share
4 Comments
Share this discussion

surprises and how to spot them

backofmind.substack.com
Chris Bertram
Jul 12Liked by Dan Davies

I thought Davies's law was ""Good ideas do not need lots of lies told about them in order to gain public acceptance"

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
1 reply
Alan Goldhammer
Jul 12Liked by Dan Davies

Aphorisms are great and your publisher should not give you grief! I have my own, "I know a little about a lot of different things." It's served me well and I can converse on about any subject coherently for 2-5 minutes.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
2 more comments...
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Dan Davies
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing